Leahy is the functional opposite of Paddack. He does not miss many bats, 34 strikeouts in 45.2 innings, but he limits the big inning and generates weak contact. He has won back-to-back starts since mid-May, allowing a single earned run in six innings against Kansas City and five scoreless frames at San Diego. His 3.07 ERA in 88 innings in 2025 says this form is not a one-year trick. St. Louis is 5-3-0 ATS in his starts this season. That is the mark of a pitcher who controls games even when the surface numbers do not pop.

The April 21 meeting between these two clubs confirms the concern about Paddack. He lasted 4.2 innings and surrendered five earned runs that day. Burleson hit .667 with a 1.667 OPS in three plate appearances against him. Wetherholt posted a .500 average with a 1.667 OPS. Winn hit .667 with a 1.667 OPS in three tries. Church added a 2.500 OPS with a home run in two plate appearances. Those are single-game samples and should be weighted accordingly, but the contact tendency of this Cardinals lineup against a pitcher who cannot miss bats is not coincidental. As one sportsbook analysis noted: "Paddack's team is 0-2 this season when he starts and they're favored on the moneyline." That number does not happen without reason.

Great American Ball Park is not a neutral backdrop. It carries a 1.18 HR factor, top three in the sport, and tonight's weather ranks third-best for offense on the full daily schedule. Paddack has already surrendered six home runs in 35.2 innings this season. Jordan Walker leads St. Louis with 13 home runs and posts a .920 OPS against right-handed pitching. The park, the pitcher, and the hitter form a troubling combination for Cincinnati. The honest contrarian case is worth stating: the Reds get two relievers back from the injured list today, while St. Louis is missing two bullpen arms on the 60-day IL through June 1. If Paddack exits early and Cincinnati trails, those fresh arms could blunt a Cardinals lead in the middle innings. That structural flip is real. It just does not outweigh what happens in the first five innings when Leahy is on the mound and Paddack is not.

• Paddack is at the 23rd percentile in K% for 2026. His last three starts produced five combined strikeouts in 11.2 innings. A Cardinals lineup built on contact, not swing-and-miss, is the worst possible matchup for a pitcher with no whiff rate to fall back on.
• Leahy has allowed one earned run in his last two starts covering 11 combined innings. His 3.07 ERA across 2025 and 2026 combined speaks to a pitcher who controls games consistently, not one running hot on a small sample.
• St. Louis is 15-7 on the road this season, the best away record in the NL Central. Cincinnati is 13-11 at home. The Cardinals have not played like a road underdog all year, and the pitching matchup reinforces that dynamic tonight.
• Great American Ball Park carries a 1.18 HR factor, one of the top three venues in baseball for home runs. Tonight's weather ranks third-best for run-scoring on the full daily slate. Both factors push toward a higher total, particularly with Paddack's 1.51 HR/9 rate this season.
• Cincinnati gains two relievers returning from the IL on game day, improving late-inning depth. St. Louis is missing two bullpen arms on the 60-day IL with no reinforcements coming. If Paddack exits early and Cincinnati trails, the pen matchup flips toward the Reds in the middle innings.
• The Cardinals are 10-3 in one-run games and 7-1 in extra innings this season. When this team plays in a close game, it finds ways to win. That structural edge does not appear in ERA comparisons but matters in a near-coin-flip matchup where the final margin could be tight.

The contrarian angle deserves honest acknowledgment. Cincinnati adds two relievers from the IL today while St. Louis loses two bullpen arms through June 1. If the Cardinals build a lead and Leahy hands it to a taxed pen, the Reds have the depth to chip away. That is a real factor, and it is part of why the Over 9.5 makes sense as a secondary play rather than a primary one. The park, the weather ranked third-best for scoring today, and Paddack's contact-first profile all push toward a high run total. Confidence on the Over is LOW given the thin market edge, but the situational stack is hard to dismiss entirely. Best single angle in this game is Paddack Under 3.5 strikeouts at plus money. That number reflects what he has actually done in three consecutive starts, not what a projection model suggests. It is the most grounded play on the board.

For the full slate, see our MLB picks today, NRFI picks, and player props.