Well, that escalated quickly. The Toronto Blue Jays just sent the New York Yankees packing, and they didn’t even need a dramatic Game 5 to do it. The Jays were simply better. From the mound to the manager’s chair, Toronto had all the right answers, while the Yankees looked like they were still stuck in spring training mode. Too many free outs in the lineup, too many runners left stranded, and not nearly enough of that Bronx swagger.
Vlad Guerrero Jr. took his rightful place among the pantheon of Yankees tormentors — think Evan Longoria, Big Papi, and Freddie Freeman (for one chaotic series). Vlad absolutely feasted and finally showed why he got that monster contract. For a team that hadn’t done much in the postseason in years, Toronto made a statement.
As for the Yankees, the offseason is going to be long and full of questions. Coaching, situational hitting, and lineup construction all need serious retooling. You can’t just show up in October and expect to win on brand name alone.
With the Yankees out of the way, the Blue Jays now look ahead to face either the Detroit Tigers or the Seattle Mariners in the next round. And if you’re a Jays fan, you’re probably hoping Detroit pulls off the upset. Why? Because Seattle looks like the bigger problem.
The Mariners have one of the nastiest starting rotations left in the postseason. We’re talking Luis Castillo, Logan Gilbert, George Kirby, and Bryce Miller — all guys who can give you length and keep powerful lineups like Toronto’s honest. Sure, the bullpen’s been shaky, but that top-end starting talent is the kind of thing that can swing a seven-game series.
Detroit, on the other hand, is basically the Tarik Skubal show. The guy’s been lights out, but the team has struggled to give him run support. Schoolboy, as he's been lovingly dubbed, has been dealing with some serious “deGrom Syndrome” — all gas, no help. If he pitches in Game 5, which he likely will, that means he won’t be available again until later in the ALCS, putting even more strain on a thin pitching staff.
Offensively, Detroit doesn’t inspire a whole lot of fear. The Tigers are scrappy, sure, but outside of Riley Greene and a few hot bats here and there, they’re not built to go toe-to-toe with a one-through-nine lineup like Toronto’s.
Let’s talk odds. Detroit is the slight favorite in Game 5 with Skubal on the mound, sitting at around -140. Seattle’s coming in at +120, and there’s a lot of value in that number if you believe in home-field magic and a deep rotation. The total is hovering around 5.5 runs, and the over is getting some love, especially from bettors expecting a 4-2 or 6-1 kind of finish.
Skubal’s strikeout prop is a hot topic. It opened at 9.5, which is a big number for a guy pitching on short rest in a do-or-die game. The under might be the smarter side here, especially since he’s never hit that number against Seattle. He could still be dominant, but don’t be shocked if he gets the hook early if trouble brews.
As for player props, JP Crawford to grab a single at -115 is a popular pick — he’s got a good matchup and tends to show up in big moments. Josh Naylor at 12-to-1 and Riley Greene at 6-to-1 are drawing home run action. If you’re feeling frisky, the over on Skubal hits allowed at 3+ is another bet that’s getting attention. Seattle’s lineup is good enough to scratch together some knocks even if they don’t light up the scoreboard.
While the Blue Jays wait and the Tigers and Mariners battle, a few other postseason notes are worth tracking. The Dodgers outlasted the Phillies in 11 innings in a thriller, and the Cubs forced a Game 5 against the Braves. The home-field trend continues to be very real: home teams are 10-6 on the moneyline over the past week. Something to keep in mind as the playoffs roll on.
There’s also growing concern about Shohei Ohtani’s postseason performance, or lack thereof. He’s been a ghost at the plate — just one hit in the current series and a rough .105 average in last year’s World Series. It’s not panic time, but if the silence continues, people are going to start talking. Actually, they already are.
Back to the Tigers-Mariners series: the bullpen edge might actually go to Detroit. While Seattle’s starters are fantastic, their relievers have been shaky. Detroit’s pen, while not elite, has been surprisingly solid. If the Tigers can somehow hand over a lead after six innings, they might just squeak into the ALCS.
Looking for a complete guide on how to bet on baseball? The OddsIndex MLB Betting Guide brings you the perfect no-nonsense guide with an in-depth look into the sport, strategy, and available sportsbooks.
The Mariners’ bats and bullpen overpowered Detroit, while Aaron Judge’s clutch homer sparked a Yankees comeback. Dodgers’ pitching dominates, the splitter is trending, and Brewers are outplaying the Cubs with poise—October baseball at its most electric.
The Detroit Tigers staged a stunning 9-3 comeback over the Mariners to force a decisive Game 5 in the ALDS. Meanwhile, the Cubs evened their series against the Brewers with a strong bullpen showing and a hot Christian Yelich. The Phillies dominated the Dodgers as Kershaw struggles continue, and the Blue Jays outclassed the Yankees behind Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s hitting. Betting insights highlight momentum swings, bullpen dynamics, and key player performances shaping the playoff picture.
Whether you're Team Vlad, riding the Mariners’ pitching wave, or hoping for a Tigers upset, the road to the ALCS is heating up fast. Buckle up and get those bets in before first pitch.