Nolan McLean counters for New York with a 3.57 ERA and generally sound peripherals for a 25-year-old righty in his second full season. His last start at Washington on May 19 was a disaster, six earned runs in 5.2 innings, but the two starts before that were quality outings: seven innings in Detroit and six frames in Arizona. He arrives on six days of extended rest, a bounce-back profile if there ever was one. The Mets, though, come in having managed just 3 hits in a loss to Miami on May 24, dropping three straight while averaging less than one run per game against the Marlins. Their 3-10 record against left-handed starters is not a fluke or a small sample. Across 53 games, it is a structural problem rooted in how this roster is built and how the lineup sequences against same-side pitching.

Cincinnati enters on a win, riding Elly De La Cruz (.857 OPS over the last 28 days, 12 home runs, 9 stolen bases) and Sal Stewart, who has posted a 1.278 OPS over the past seven days. Neither has career data against McLean, which cuts both ways. The bat to watch against Lodolo specifically is Spencer Steer, who carries a 1.055 OPS against left-handed pitching in 2026. With Lodolo unable to throw strikes consistently, Steer will see pitches to handle. Juan Soto is the one Mets hitter who can flip this game on its head. He has posted a 1.371 OPS over the last seven days and owns a 1.666 OPS across three career plate appearances against Lodolo, including a home run. If Lodolo falls behind in counts and Soto gets pitches to drive, the Mets' LHP struggles become less relevant in a hurry.

Citi Field works against high-scoring outcomes. The park's run factor sits at 0.96 and the home run factor at 0.92, a spacious outfield that suppresses crooked numbers even when starters are struggling. That context matters for both the total and the run line. As Amazin' Avenue reported, "Both Jared Young and A.J. Minter are nearing a return for the Mets," which could add depth to a roster that has looked thin in the rotation behind McLean and in the back of the bullpen. For now, this is a game built around two pitchers with meaningful command questions, a run-suppressing park, and a Mets lineup that historically falls flat against left-handers.

• The Mets' 3-10 record against left-handed starters covers 53 games. That is a roster-construction problem, not a hot streak for opposing lefties. Individual hitters like Vientos show a .842 OPS vs LHP, yet the team still loses at a 23% clip against that handedness.
• Lodolo walked 9 batters in 15 innings this season. Free runners are coming. But a Mets lineup that is 3-10 against lefties has consistently stranded those runners rather than converting them into runs, which is exactly the disconnect that makes the run total unpredictable.
• Citi Field carries a 0.96 run factor and a 0.92 home run factor. One of the more spacious outfields in the NL actively works against both starters finding their best results and against the Over thesis on any line near 7.5.
• McLean's last start (6 ER in 5.2 IP) raises early-exit risk. Both bullpens are fresh entering Game 1 of the series, which could absorb a short outing without allowing the game to blow open.
• Soto's three career plate appearances against Lodolo include a home run and a 1.666 OPS. That small sample carries real weight given Lodolo's current walk rate. If Soto reaches base early on walks and then gets a hittable pitch, this game's total could move quickly.
• Steer posts a 1.055 OPS against left-handed pitching in 2026. With Lodolo walking batters at a historic rate for his career, Steer is positioned as Cincinnati's most dangerous bat in this specific matchup.

The best single play on the board is Lodolo Under 5.5 strikeouts at -122. Three strikeouts, six strikeouts, two strikeouts. His recent starts do the talking. Steer Over 0.5 hits is the complementary prop, a batter with a 1.055 OPS against left-handers facing a walk-prone lefty in a park that still produces contact. The contrarian argument worth acknowledging is that Soto's 1.371 OPS over the last seven days and his career damage against Lodolo (1.666 OPS in 3 PA, including a home run) represent the single biggest threat to the Under and run-line plays. If Lodolo falls behind in counts early and Soto gets a pitch to drive, this game can change in one at-bat. The run-line and total both carry meaningful variance. Size down accordingly.

For the full slate, see our MLB picks today, NRFI picks, and player props.