The New York Yankees arrive as the hottest team on the slate, 21-9 in their last 30 games and 8-2 in their last 10, having already posted a 9-2 blowout in Game 1 of this series. Arizona is moving in the opposite direction: 4-6 in the last 10, losers of three straight after dropping two to Miami following a series loss to Texas. Their situation carries urgency with a wild card spot still in play, but their numbers against right-handed pitching are the structural problem tonight. The Diamondbacks are 53-61 (.465) against righties in 2026, compared to 27-13 (.675) against left-handers. That is a 21-game swing in outcomes based purely on pitcher handedness, one of the starkest splits in the entire league this season. Schlittler throws right-handed. The lineup he is facing has a documented, season-long vulnerability to exactly what he does.

The batter-vs-pitcher data sharpens the picture further. Cody Bellinger is 2-for-7 with a 1.518 OPS and 2 home runs in 8 career plate appearances against Pfaadt, and he is hitting a .970 OPS over his last 28 days. He brings both historical success against tonight's starter and strong current form into the same at-bat. Luis García Jr. is 3-for-7 against Pfaadt with a 1.429 OPS and 1 home run. García is slashing .283/.314/.538 this season with 30 home runs. On the opposite end, Ryan McMahon is 0-for-10 (.000 AVG, .000 OPS) against Pfaadt across three separate seasons of exposure. Three years, ten trips to the plate, zero hits. That kind of consistency is not a coincidence. Chase Field plays with a mild 1.08 home run factor, which is relevant given how much extra-base pop the Yankees bring against a pitcher who has allowed 14 home runs in 124.0 innings this year. Jesús Sánchez carries the strongest Arizona track record against Schlittler at a .333 average and .800 OPS across 15 plate appearances, but the rest of the Diamondbacks lineup has no career data against him at all. Most of this roster is walking into an 11.12 K/9 pitcher for the first time, in tonight's MLB action, with a cold offense and three losses in a row behind them.

The first-inning setup is worth flagging before the first pitch. Both starters are working with extended rest, six days for Schlittler and seven for Pfaadt, and both should be sharp early. Arizona's lineup has averaged 2.3 runs per game over its last three outings. Schlittler's combination of velocity and secondaries against a lineup with no prior exposure to him makes a quiet first inning for the home side a very real probability. When the slate's most dominant strikeout arm opens a game against a cold offense, the first inning tends to be the safest ground on the board.

• Schlittler's 11.12 K/9 rate and his three-start floor of 8 strikeouts position him for another dominant performance against a lineup that is 53-61 against right-handed pitching, the team's most documented weakness in 2026.
• Arizona's handedness split is one of the starkest in the league: .675 win rate against left-handers versus .465 against righties, a 21-game gap that maps directly onto tonight's matchup against a right-handed starter.
• Pfaadt allowed 6 earned runs in his last start against Texas and has surrendered 14 home runs in 124.0 innings this season. García Jr. (1.429 OPS vs Pfaadt in 7 PA) and Bellinger (1.518 OPS in 8 PA, 2 HR) are exactly the power profile that exploits his tendencies.
• Ryan McMahon is 0-for-10 with a .000 OPS against Pfaadt across 2023, 2024, and 2025. His current season slump (.208 AVG, .393 OPS in last 28 days) compounds the concern. This is one of the strongest individual under signals in the data.
• Most of the Arizona lineup has no career matchup data against Schlittler at all, meaning they approach tonight's start without any prior exposure to his pitch mix. Walking in blind against an 11.12 K/9 arm, with a cold offense, is not a formula for contact production.
• Both starters carry extended rest (6-7 days) and project to command the early innings. Arizona's 2.3 R/G over the last three games and Schlittler's first-inning dominance make a scoreless opening frame a reasonable expectation from both sides.

The contrarian case deserves honest treatment. Arizona at +128 on the moneyline has real logic behind it: Pfaadt's 3.77 ERA is genuine, the Diamondbacks need wins with their playoff spot on the line, and one-game blowouts often produce motivated responses. Their 28-21 record in one-run games shows this team can grind close contests. But bouncing back from a 9-2 loss while facing arguably the most dominant starter in the American League this season is a difficult combination. Schlittler's 1.95 ERA is not a three-week sample. It is a 184.2-inning body of work with no signs of regression. The risk on the Yankees side is a short outing or unexpected early trouble opening the game up, which does happen to even the best pitchers. No pick is a guarantee. But when the data and the matchup alignment both point in the same direction this clearly, fading it requires more evidence than the bounce-back narrative provides.

For the full slate, see our MLB picks today, NRFI picks, and player props.