We couldn't load the latest odds.
Refresh in a few minutes, they usually come right back.
MLB→Game Previews→Baltimore Orioles at New York Yankees

Score Prediction

Pre-match Prediction
Baltimore Orioles
@
New York Yankees
Baltimore Orioles 45%New York Yankees 55%
Market LinesRun Line: New York Yankees -1Total: O/U 7.5
↑
Model: Over 7.5
Model projects 7.7 total runs vs 7.5 line

Baltimore Orioles

0022446688101012121414OVERUNDERO/U 7.5Runs ScoredRuns Allowed
All Over 7.5
60%
97/161
MLB: 48%
Starter
52%
16/31
vs NYY
67%
8/12
Avg Total
9.0
MLB: 8.9
Game Starter (31) Last Starter vs NYY vs NYY (12)
Shane Baz #34 · RHP · Age 27
4.11
ERA (2026)
7.7
K/9 (2026)
31
Starts (2026)
7.8
Avg Total (2026)
Last 3:
ND TOR (Sep 21): 6.2IP, 3ER, 2K
ND @NYM (Sep 15): 4.0IP, 3ER, 2K
W CLE (Sep 09): 5.2IP, 5ER, 5K
vs NYY: L (Aug 19 2025): 3.0 IP, 6 ER, 3 K
Bullpen (2026 Season)Average
ERA: 3.87MLB Avg: 3.9511 relievers
Recent: W 4-3W 4-2W 4-2W 10-2L 3-6
Lineup vs Shane Baz (Career)
BatterPosPAAVGOPSHR
Jazz Chisholm Jr.2B13.4171.2121
Austin WellsC11.3751.2951
Ben RiceDH11.0000.1820
Paul Goldschmidt1B9.2500.5830
Anthony VolpeSS8.1430.3930
Luis Garcia Jr.1B7.0000.0000
Heliot RamosLF6.2000.5330
Cody BellingerLF5.5001.6501
Ryan McMahon3B5.2500.6500
Jose CaballeroSS4.2501.2501
George Lombard Jr.SS3.6671.3340
Spencer JonesCF3.3330.6660
2 batters with no matchup history

New York Yankees

0022446688101012121414OVERUNDERO/U 7.5Runs ScoredRuns Allowed
All Over 7.5
52%
84/161
MLB: 48%
Starter
67%
4/6
vs BAL
67%
8/12
Avg Total
8.3
MLB: 8.9
Game Starter (6) Last Starter vs BAL vs BAL (12)
Elmer Rodriguez #71 · RHP · Age 23
5.40
ERA (2026)
7.2
K/9 (2026)
6
Starts (2026)
9.2
Avg Total (2026)
Last 3:
L @LAA (Aug 31): 3.2IP, 4ER, 5K
ND HOU (Aug 26): 6.0IP, 3ER, 6K
L CIN (Jun 21): 4.0IP, 3ER, 4K
Bullpen (2026 Season)Good
ERA: 3.14MLB Avg: 3.9510 relievers
⚠
Workload Alert: Allowed 10 runs on 2026-09-25 vs BAL. Bullpen arms likely still recovering.
Recent: L 1-6W 9-2W 6-4L 2-10W 6-3
Lineup vs Elmer Rodriguez (Career)
No career matchup data — first meaningful meeting
Our Top PicksLive Odds
Top PickBaltimore Orioles ML (+102), MEDIUM conf
Baltimore Orioles ML (+102), MEDIUM confidence. Getting Baltimore at essentially even money against a 0-3 starter with a 5.40 ERA is genuine value. Th...
PickBaltimore Orioles +1.5 (-204), MEDIUM co
Baltimore Orioles +1.5 (-204), MEDIUM confidence. The predicted game flow is a tight 4-3 Baltimore win or a close New York win. Either way, the Oriole...
PickUnder 7.5 total runs (-103), LOW confide
Under 7.5 total runs (-103), LOW confidence. The model lines up with the 7.5 total, producing no directional edge, which keeps confidence low. But the...
Deposit $10, get a $50 trading bonus
Trade on Polymarket

18+ Only. Restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Not available in all jurisdictions. Trading involves high risk and may result in loss of your entire investment. See polymarket.us/tos for more information. The Polymarket US App serves as an independent software provider and affiliate of Polymarket US and Polymarket Clearing, the CFTC-regulated derivatives exchange and clearing organization.

Baltimore Orioles vs New York Yankees Game Preview

The Baltimore Orioles send Shane Baz to the mound against a New York Yankees club that is handing a playoff-positioning game to Elmer Rodríguez. Baz carries a 6-15 record and 4.11 ERA this season, but that profile looks like an ace compared to what New York is running out. Rodríguez is 0-3 with a 5.40 ERA and has issued 16 walks in 26.2 innings, a 5.4 BB/9 rate that will keep runners on base all afternoon. The Yankees are a 93-win team asking a 23-year-old to hold the line in a game that matters. That is a dangerous ask.

As the Yankees confirmed ahead of today's contest: "The New York Yankees have announced that the start time of Sunday's Yankees-Orioles game has been moved to 1:05 p.m. ET due to the current forecast of inclement weather." That earlier start means bettors are working with shifting conditions at Yankee Stadium, where wind could suppress fly-ball distances and crimp strikeout rates. Worth monitoring. Baz has his own recent struggles, posting just 2, 2, and 5 strikeouts across his last three outings. He is not missing bats right now. But his ERA still holds at 4.11, and his walk rate for the season sits at a manageable 3.15 BB/9. Against Rodríguez's 5.4 BB/9, that gap is enormous. Baltimore went 6-4 in their last 10 games and is 40-40 away from home this season, a perfectly respectable road record for a club playing out the string.

The most dangerous bat in today's MLB action is Pete Alonso, who owns a 1.423 OPS over his last seven days and has hit 43 home runs this season. He faces Rodríguez with no career matchup data between them, meaning there is no history to game-plan around. That is purely a red-hot slugger against a struggling 23-year-old in a park with a 1.15 home run factor and a short right-field porch that turns deep fly balls into souvenirs. Meanwhile, Ben Rice, the Yankees' 41-home-run DH and their most feared power bat, is 0-for-11 lifetime against Baz with a .182 OPS across three separate seasons. No misread of small samples here. That is 2024, 2025, and 2026 combined, and Rice has not been able to make contact against Baz in any of them. New York's most reliable offensive weapon is essentially neutralized before the first pitch.

If the starters get through four or five innings, this game belongs to the bullpens. New York's relief corps holds a 3.14 ERA, among the best in baseball. Baltimore checks in at 3.87, still well above average. In a season-finale context with Baltimore out of contention and the Yankees managing workloads, both managers will pull their starters early and hand the ball to their best relievers. The edge doesn't care what sport you're watching, and the formula here is the same as any tight game: the bullpen advantage narrows the more the starters struggle, and both starters are built to struggle today.

Baltimore Orioles vs New York Yankees Key Insights

  • Elmer Rodríguez has issued 16 walks in 26.2 innings this season, a 5.4 BB/9 rate that creates constant traffic. He is 0-3 with a 1.58 WHIP and has not completed five innings in two of his last three outings.
  • Ben Rice, the Yankees' primary power threat with 41 home runs, is 0-for-11 lifetime against Shane Baz with a .182 OPS across 2024, 2025, and 2026. This is not a small-sample fluke. It is a consistent inability to make contact across three separate seasons against the Orioles' starter.
  • Pete Alonso enters on a historic personal run: 1.423 OPS in his last seven days, 43 home runs on the season, .363 OBP, .522 SLG. He faces a pitcher with no career data against him at a park with a 1.15 HR factor. That is as clean a matchup edge as you will find.
  • Baz has posted 2, 2, and 5 strikeouts in his last three outings, averaging 3.0 Ks per start. His season K/9 of roughly 7.7 masks a dramatic late-season decline in swing-and-miss production that makes the under 4.5 strikeouts bet genuinely appealing.
  • Both bullpens are elite. New York holds a 3.14 ERA out of the bullpen, Baltimore is at 3.87. In a season-finale spot, expect short starter leashes and shutdown relief work in the final three innings, suppressing late-game run production for both clubs.
  • Weather forced the start time up to 1:05 p.m. ET. Early-game conditions at Yankee Stadium could affect fly-ball distance and whiff rates. If the game is delayed past the moved-up start, strikeout prop lines may shift further toward the under.

Baltimore Orioles vs New York Yankees Betting Picks

Picks made September 27, 2026 at 06:27 AM ET. Odds shown reflect current market prices.

Baltimore Orioles +1.5 (-204), MEDIUM co
Baltimore Orioles +1.5 (-204), MEDIUM confidence. The predicted game flow is a tight 4-3 Baltimore win or a close New York win. Either way, the Orioles cover 1.5 runs. Rodríguez's walk rate means Baltimore will manufacture early baserunners regardless of hard contact. The -204 price is steep, but in a game this evenly matched at the pitching level, paying for the cushion makes sense.
Under 7.5 total runs (-103), LOW confide
Under 7.5 total runs (-103), LOW confidence. The model lines up with the 7.5 total, producing no directional edge, which keeps confidence low. But the game context supports the under: two flawed starters who will exit early, elite bullpens on both sides, and a season-finale environment where managers protect their best arms. The late-game scoring environment should be suppressed significantly once the starters exit. Play this one small given the low confidence designation.
Shane Baz Under 4.5 strikeouts (-104), M
Shane Baz Under 4.5 strikeouts (-104), MEDIUM confidence. Baz has posted 2, 2, and 5 strikeouts in his last three outings. His per-start average over that stretch is 3.0 Ks. The outs market projects roughly 5.2 innings from him today. At his current contact-heavy rate, that projects to about 4.4 strikeouts. The August 18 start against New York where he struck out 10 is the outlier that inflates his season number. Recent form is the story here.
Ben Rice Under 0.5 hits (+150), HIGH con
Ben Rice Under 0.5 hits (+150), HIGH confidence. This is the cleanest signal in the data. Rice is 0-for-11 lifetime against Baz with a .182 OPS, producing zero hits across 2024, 2025, and 2026. He cannot make contact against this pitcher. Getting +150 on a 0-for-career matchup result is the best value on the board today.
Luis García Jr. Under 0.5 hits (+154), M
Luis García Jr. Under 0.5 hits (+154), MEDIUM confidence. García went 0-for-7 against Baz in 2026 with a .000 AVG and 0.000 OPS. That is 7 plate appearances without a single hit this season against this specific pitcher. His road form compounds the concern: .568 OPS over the last 28 days, .417 OPS in the last 7. At +154, the under carries real value given the zero-hit BvP profile.
Pete Alonso to hit a home run (+330), LO
Pete Alonso to hit a home run (+330), LOW confidence. Alonso leads Baltimore with 43 home runs and is scorching right now at a 1.423 OPS over his last seven days. He faces Rodríguez, who carries a 5.40 ERA and a 1.58 WHIP, at Yankee Stadium where the HR park factor is 1.15. No career data exists between these two, so there is no sample-size discount to apply. The +330 price reflects reasonable value for a 43-HR bat in this environment. Play it small given the inherent variance of home run props.
Elmer Rodríguez Under 4.5 strikeouts (+1
Elmer Rodríguez Under 4.5 strikeouts (+100), MEDIUM confidence. Rodríguez averages roughly 3.5 strikeouts per start across his 2026 appearances. The market's outs line of 14.5 suggests an expectation of about 4.8 innings today, which projects to roughly 3.8 strikeouts at his current rate. If Baltimore gets to him early, as the game flow suggests, he exits before accumulating enough outs to reach 4.5 Ks. Getting even money on the under against the -141 over price is the right side.
SGP
SGP: Baltimore Orioles +1.5 / Under 7.5 / Ben Rice Under 0.5 hits / Luis García Jr. Under 0.5 hits. These four legs move in the same direction. A low-scoring, tight game where Baltimore stays within 1.5 runs naturally suppresses individual hit totals for Yankees batters facing Baz. The same pitching-controls-the-environment script that supports the game total under also supports Rice and García finishing hitless. These legs correlate cleanly, which is exactly what you want when building a same-game parlay.
Analysis insight — no specific bet associated
YRFI (-110). Baz is on a four-game strea
YRFI (-110). Baz is on a four-game streak of allowing first-inning runs, and his 1.35 WHIP means he consistently allows traffic. Rodríguez's 1.58 WHIP signals constant baserunner trouble from the first pitch. Neither team has a strong NRFI profile. At -110, the YRFI offers fair value relative to the NRFI price of -137 given how both starters set up early in ballgames.

Key Players

Batting AverageBAL
Pete Alonso
.267Batting Average
1B
Home RunsBAL
Pete Alonso
43Home Runs
1B
Runs Batted InBAL
Pete Alonso
113Runs Batted In
1B
Earned Run AverageBAL
Trevor Rogers
4.03Earned Run Average
SP
WinsBAL
Trevor Rogers
10Wins
SP
StrikeoutsBAL
Trevor Rogers
157Strikeouts
SP
Batting AverageNYY
Cody Bellinger
.264Batting Average
LF
Home RunsNYY
Ben Rice
41Home Runs
DH
Runs Batted InNYY
Ben Rice
97Runs Batted In
DH
Earned Run AverageNYY
Cam Schlittler
1.95Earned Run Average
SP
WinsNYY
Cam Schlittler
14Wins
SP
StrikeoutsNYY
Cam Schlittler
239Strikeouts
SP

Recent Form

Baltimore Orioles
W4-3Toronto Blue Jays
W4-2Toronto Blue Jays
W4-2Toronto Blue Jays
W10-2New York Yankees
L6-3New York Yankees
New York Yankees
L6-1Tampa Bay Rays
W9-2Tampa Bay Rays
W6-4Tampa Bay Rays
L10-2Baltimore Orioles
W6-3Baltimore Orioles

Baltimore Orioles vs New York Yankees Summary

The core thesis today is simple: a struggling 23-year-old with a 5.40 ERA is pitching in a game that matters for the Yankees, and Baltimore is getting near-even money to beat him. The market prices New York as a -152 favorite, implying 60.2% win probability. That number assumes home field and lineup depth carry the day. But home field means less when your starter is walking batters at a 5.4 BB/9 clip, and lineup depth means less when your best hitter is 0-for-career against the opposing starter. Alonso's 1.423 OPS over his last seven days gives Baltimore a weapon Rodríguez has no blueprint for. The Orioles ML at +102, the run line at +1.5, and the under 7.5 collectively paint the same picture: a tight, low-scoring game where Baltimore wins outright or loses by one with both bullpens locking it down late.

The best single angle remains Ben Rice Under 0.5 hits at +150. Three seasons of 0-for-11 with a .182 OPS is not noise. That is the cleanest bet on the board. The caveat applies to every play today: New York's bullpen is a legitimate equalizer. If Rodríguez somehow navigates four or five innings without a blowup, the Yankees' 3.14-ERA relief corps can protect a one-run lead against anyone. The game can turn on a single inning of Rodríguez competence, which history says is possible but not probable. Play the Orioles at plus money, back the under in the total, and let Ben Rice's historical futility against Baz pay for it.

For the full slate, see our MLB picks today, NRFI picks, and player props.

Head-to-Head History

Season SeriesSeries tied 1-1
DateMatchupResult
Sep 25, 2026BAL @ NYYBALBAL 10-2
Sep 25, 2026BAL @ NYYNYYNYY 6-3

Baltimore Orioles vs New York Yankees predictions: Orioles ML +102 vs Rodríguez's 5.40 ERA. Under 7.5 backed by elite bullpens. Ben Rice 0-for-11 vs Baz.

Frequently Asked Questions

MLB→Game Previews→Baltimore Orioles at New York Yankees