Nick Martinez is dealing. The Tampa Bay Rays righty enters Friday at 4-1 with a 1.51 ERA and 1.043 WHIP across 53.2 innings in 2026. His last three starts: 0 ER in 6.0 IP against Miami, 1 ER in 5.2 IP at Boston, 1 ER in 5.0 IP against Toronto. He has issued just 11 walks all season. His approach is contact management rather than swing-and-miss volume, and it has been brutal to hit against. In tonight's MLB action, that kind of consistency is the hardest profile for an offense to solve.

The New York Yankees enter this one having dropped their last two games to Toronto, sitting 30-21 overall. Tampa Bay arrives at Yankee Stadium on a four-game winning streak at 33-15, the best record in the American League. Yandy Díaz is the first name to examine from a betting standpoint. He carries a .318 average and 0.875 OPS across 48 career plate appearances against Cole, with two home runs in that sample. That is not a small number. Multi-year, multi-season data that never resolved in Cole's favor. Layer on top his current form: 1.650 OPS over the last seven days, the hottest bat on this entire roster right now. The historical matchup edge backed by peak present-day form is a rare combination.

Yankee Stadium's home run park factor sits at 1.15, and that short right-field porch is unforgiving to pitchers who miss over the plate. A starter returning from 7-plus months of inactivity almost certainly faces pitch-count management, meaning Cole likely exits around the fourth or fifth inning. That shifts the burden to New York's bullpen well before the late frames. Junior Caminero, Tampa Bay's young power bat at 13 HR and a 1.208 OPS over the last seven days, has no career data against Cole. No scouting book. No pitch-sequencing history to lean on. That absence of a matchup record actually benefits the hitter.

• Cole has thrown exactly 0 innings in 2026, with his last competitive appearance coming in the October 2024 World Series. A 7-plus month absence without competitive action points toward pitch-count limits and mechanical uncertainty in the early innings.
• Martinez's contact-suppression profile is elite this season: 1.51 ERA, 1.043 WHIP, and just 11 walks in 53.2 innings. His K/9 of 5.9 understates how effective he has been. He has allowed only 3 home runs all year, and his ground-ball approach keeps the ball away from that short right-field porch at Yankee Stadium.
• Tampa Bay is 5-1 when Martinez starts as a moneyline underdog this season. The market has consistently undervalued these starts, and tonight's situation, an elite starter going against an unknown quantity on the mound, is the clearest underdog-value setup yet.
• Yandy Díaz brings a .318 average and 0.875 OPS across 48 career PA against Cole, including 2 HR. His last seven days produced a 1.650 OPS. That combination of deep historical matchup data and peak current form is the strongest individual edge in this game.
• Taylor Walls is hitless across 10 career PA against Cole with a 0.200 OPS, going 0-for-6 in 2022 alone. That is as clean a batter-versus-pitcher under signal as this dataset provides.
• Both bullpens are mid-tier by ERA (Yankees 3.47, Rays 3.75). With Cole likely exiting early and Martinez averaging around five to six innings per start, both relievers see significant action. That dynamic pushes run totals higher regardless of how either starter performs.

The contrarian read deserves a clear acknowledgment: if the Yankees medical staff has genuinely cleared Cole for a full workload, his track record at Yankee Stadium and elite strikeout profile make New York the correct pick at the price. Watch for late line movement toward the Yankees before first pitch on Friday. Significant movement in that direction is the signal that sharps have information about Cole's health and pitch-count ceiling that is not yet public. Without that movement, the edge stays with Tampa Bay, and the props on both starters staying under 4.5 strikeouts offer the clearest individual value on the board.

For the full slate, see our MLB picks today, NRFI picks, and player props.