On the Washington side, Richard Lovelady enters listed as the starter, but that framing is misleading. Lovelady pitched 0.2 innings on September 19, 0.2 innings on September 16, and 1.0 inning on September 15. He has not recorded more than one strikeout in any of those appearances. He is being deployed as an opener, and Detroit will see a different Washington arm by the third inning at the latest. This is not a pitching matchup. It is Valdez versus a Washington committee bullpen that carries a 4.33 ERA and arrives in game three of this series with arms already stretched. Per NBCSports.com, Verlander threw a clean bullpen session Tuesday and is locked in for Saturday's start, which means Detroit's high-leverage relief arms enter today completely fresh.

Comerica Park adds another layer to the pitching-friendly forecast. The park runs at a 0.97 runs factor and 0.92 for home runs. Spacious outfield, suppressed offense. Washington's offense grades out at 5.1 R/G on the season and .745 OPS overall, which is respectable. But those numbers come against a mix of starters. Today they face a proven southpaw and a park that punishes anyone looking to elevate the ball. Washington's 7-3 run over their last 10 games is real momentum, and their away record of 37-43 is not bad for a team 18.5 games out. The contrarian case for Washington at +158 is not imaginary. Detroit is also eliminated, the effort and lineup construction in an afternoon game three are genuinely uncertain. But motivational vacuums apply equally to both teams, and the pitching asymmetry is concrete where the effort argument is speculative.

The career matchup data against Valdez cuts Washington's offense down fast. CJ Abrams is 0-for-5 in his career against Valdez, posting a .200 OPS across 5 plate appearances in 2023 and 2025. Keibert Ruiz is 6-for-30 caliber, posting a .533 career OPS in 6 PA against him. Brady House, Daylen Lile, and Jacob Young are a combined 0-for-6 in their limited looks. More than half the Washington lineup has no career data against Valdez at all, which means they walk into the batter's box cold against a sinker-heavy lefty profile they almost never see. That is a real disadvantage in a game that may be decided by the fifth inning.

• Richard Lovelady is operating as a one-inning reliever. He has exceeded 1.0 IP exactly once in his last 11 outings. Detroit faces a different Washington arm by the third inning regardless of how the game flows.
• Valdez's two starts before Chicago were scoreless across 13.0 innings. His command was on point (3 walks combined) and his sinker generated weak contact rather than strikeouts. That profile is exactly what today's matchup calls for.
• Every Washington batter with career data against Valdez posts a .533 OPS or below. CJ Abrams, the most dangerous bat in the lineup, is 0-for-5 against Valdez lifetime and carries a weaker split against left-handed pitching (vL OPS: 0.703 vs vR: 0.898).
• Comerica Park's 0.97 runs factor and 0.92 HR factor suppress scoring across the board. A Valdez quality start in this park is a ceiling-capping environment for Washington's offense.
• Washington's bullpen enters game three of this series depleted. Five or six innings of relief work from a 4.33-ERA group, against a Detroit lineup with multiple hot bats in the bottom half, creates a structural run-margin opportunity for Detroit.
• The sharp contrarian angle is WSH +158 (38.8% market-implied probability): Detroit is eliminated, Valdez's 2026 ERA has climbed, and Washington is playing with momentum at 7-3 in their last 10. Acknowledge the variance. But the pitching gap is too real to fade entirely on motivational arguments.

The best single entry point is Detroit -1.5 at +104. Plus-money on the favorite covering the run line is where the value concentrates. Pair it with the Lovelady Under 1.5 strikeouts as your highest-confidence leg if you are building a parlay. For those drawn to the props, Valencia Over 1.5 total bases at +126 stands out as the most underpriced individual bet given his recent form and the matchup he faces. This is a late-September afternoon game between two eliminated teams in a pitcher-friendly park. Neither lineup will put up a crooked number without a collapse. Plan your unit sizing accordingly and respect that garbage-time September baseball carries variance that no amount of structural analysis fully eliminates.

For the full slate, see our MLB picks today, NRFI picks, and player props.