Young's last start, 3.2 innings and 6 earned runs against Cleveland, stands as an outlier. Two starts before that he went 7.0 innings against Oakland and allowed one run. Three outings back it was 6.2 innings against Boston with three earned. One rough outing does not define a pitcher with a 3.71 ERA and a 19-6 ATS record built across a full season. He arrives with six days of rest. Tong comes in with seven days of extended rest after going 5.0 innings in Miami on September 7. His previous two 2026 starts produced 3.1 and 3.2 innings respectively, creating real early-exit risk. The Mets bullpen carries a 4.89 ERA this season, so if Tong exits in the third or fourth, Baltimore gets a favorable matchup against that unit in what should already be a tight game.

Baltimore brings Pete Alonso, who is running a 1.074 OPS over his last seven days with 35 home runs on the season. Facing a 23-year-old with 15.0 innings of 2026 evidence, Alonso is the primary power threat in this game and the most likely reason Tong could face an early exit. Coby Mayo has posted a 1.083 OPS over the last seven days, and Gunnar Henderson is holding steady at 0.808. On the Mets side, Brett Baty has been electric with a 1.203 OPS over his last week, and Francisco Lindor is running a 1.069 OPS over that same stretch. Still, the Mets were shut out 2-0 by the Yankees on Sunday, and a rested Young at 3.71 ERA is a considerably tougher assignment than what New York faced in that series finale.

Citi Field plays as a mild pitcher's park. The run factor sits at 0.96 and the home run factor at 0.92, both nudging toward a lower-scoring environment. The public will load up on the Mets at home off their 7-3 L10 form, but sharp money sees the Orioles ATS signal and a near-even price on a veteran who covers at a 76% clip this season. Baltimore has gone 36-39 on the road, competitive even through their recent 3-7 stretch. No career matchup data exists between any Baltimore batter and Tong, removing one layer of preparation advantage for the Mets going into this start.

• Brandon Young is 19-6 ATS across 25 starts in 2026. The market has repriced him 25 times and still undervalues him. At +104, you are getting near-even money on a pitcher who covers at a 76% rate this season.
• Jonah Tong has thrown just 15.0 innings in 2026 across three starts, with outings of 3.1, 3.2, and 5.0 innings. Two of three ended before the fourth inning, putting the Mets bullpen, which carries a 4.89 ERA, into play early and often.
• The Mets were shut out 2-0 by the Yankees on Sunday. Entering this game with offensive uncertainty against a 3.71 ERA starter on extended rest is not an ideal combination for New York at home.
• Pete Alonso carries a 1.074 OPS over his last seven days with 35 home runs. He faces a 23-year-old with 15 innings of 2026 experience and no career matchup data against Baltimore's lineup. Alonso is the single biggest swing factor on either side of the total.
• Brett Baty is among the hottest hitters on either roster right now, posting a 1.203 OPS over his last seven days and 1.096 over 28 days. That form makes the over 0.5 hits prop compelling at modest juice.
• Both starters arrive with extended rest and Citi Field runs a 0.96 run factor with a 0.92 home run factor. That combination points cleanly toward a scoreless first inning for both sides.

The best single bet is Orioles moneyline at +104. Young's 19-6 ATS record across 25 starts is not a streak or a scheduling artifact. It is a season-long signal that the market reliably misprices him relative to his team's overall record. Baltimore at 3-7 over their last 10 is the noise. Young's 3.71 ERA with 112 strikeouts in 140.2 innings is the signal. Tong debuting as a moneyline favorite with 15 innings of 2026 evidence against an Alonso-led lineup is a situational spot worth targeting, and the market has not closed that gap at +104. The honest caveat: Alonso at +285 to go deep exists because he genuinely can against any pitcher on any given night, and one swing rearranges the run total quickly. Size accordingly if you are pairing the homer prop with the under.

For the full slate, see our MLB picks today, NRFI picks, and player props.