What's wild is how the market still sees this. Liverpool are favored at minus-140 despite playing their fifth-worst away record in the league this season. They've won three matches in their last 22 when playing away against top-half teams. Everton sit in 10th place. That's top-half. This isn't a quality mismatch on paper, but the road form says otherwise. When David Moyes took this project, he said: "A bit sad to leave Goodison because it was so important to me, my family, everybody over many years. But leaving it in a good way was pleasing." Everton have turned that page literally and tactically. They've won two straight at home in the new stadium. They're conceding 1.2 goals per game over five matches. They smell blood.
Salah plays his final Merseyside derby before leaving Liverpool. That's a legacy moment that cuts both ways. Inspiration or fatigue? You can't price emotion, but you can price structure. And the structure here favors Everton in a way the odds don't fully reflect.
Picks made April 18, 2026 at 05:30 PM ET. Odds shown reflect current market prices.
My call is Everton at +230 paired with Under 2.5 Goals. This match feels like a 1-0 or 1-1 finish, decided by a set piece or a rare lapse in concentration. Everton have home advantage, new-stadium momentum, and a Liverpool side missing their top scorer. That's not guaranteeing anything in a derby where pride and chaos live, but it's offering value that the market hasn't fully priced.
One caveat: draws happen in the Premier League roughly 27% of the time, and given how tactically locked both sides figure to be, that's a very real outcome. But I'll take the Everton underdog value at these odds over the coin-flip. For more predictions, check our Premier League picks today and BTTS picks.
Compare odds for EVE @ LIV